Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS): Measuring and Optimizing Visual Stability

Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS) is a user-centric metric that measures the visual stability of a web page. It is one of the three Core Web Vitals introduced by Google as part of their Page Experience signals. CLS quantifies how often users experience unexpected layout shifts during the entire lifespan of a page load and interaction.

Definition and Importance

CLS measures the sum total of all individual layout shift scores for every unexpected layout shift that occurs during the entire lifespan of the page. A layout shift occurs any time a visible element changes its position from one rendered frame to the next.

Why CLS Matters

• Improves user experience by reducing frustration caused by unexpected content movements
• Serves as a key indicator of a page's overall visual stability
• Directly impacts SEO as one of Google's Core Web Vitals
• Affects user trust and engagement with the website

How CLS is Calculated

The CLS score is calculated using the following formula:

CLS = Impact Fraction * Distance Fraction

• Impact Fraction: Measures how unstable elements impact the viewport area between two frames
• Distance Fraction: Measures the distance that unstable elements have moved relative to the viewport

Interpreting CLS Scores

CLS Score	Rating	Interpretation
0.1 or less	Good	Page has good visual stability
0.1 to 0.25	Needs Improvement	Page has noticeable layout shifts that should be addressed
Above 0.25	Poor	Page has significant layout stability issues that need immediate attention

Common Causes of Poor CLS

1. Images without dimensions: Images that lack width and height attributes
2. Ads, embeds, and iframes without dimensions: Dynamic content that loads after the main content
3. Dynamically injected content: Content added to the page after the initial load
4. Web Fonts causing FOIT/FOUT: Flash of Invisible Text (FOIT) or Flash of Unstyled Text (FOUT)
5. Actions waiting for a network response before updating DOM: Content that shifts after user interaction

Strategies to Improve CLS

1. Optimize Images and Videos

• Always include width and height attributes on images and video elements
• Use aspect ratio boxes to reserve space for responsive images
• Avoid inserting new content above existing content unless in response to user interaction

2. Handle Ads Responsibly

• Reserve space for ad slots in advance
• Avoid collapsing reserved ad space if there's no ad to display
• Eliminate shifts by reserving the largest possible size for the ad slot

3. Manage Dynamic Content Carefully

• Pre-allocate space for dynamic content
• Avoid inserting new content above existing content
• Use transform animations instead of animations of properties that trigger layout changes

4. Optimize Web Fonts

• Use font-display: optional or font-display: swap in @font-face rules
• Preload key web fonts
• Use the Font Loading API to reduce the time it takes to get necessary fonts

Measuring CLS

Several tools are available to measure and monitor CLS:

• Lighthouse: Provides CLS scores and suggestions for improvement
• Chrome DevTools: Use the Performance panel to identify and debug layout shifts
• PageSpeed Insights: Offers both lab and field data for CLS
• Search Console: Provides a Core Web Vitals report including CLS data
• Web Vitals Extension: Chrome extension for real-time CLS measurement

CLS and SEO

As part of the Core Web Vitals, CLS plays a significant role in SEO:

• Directly influences Google's Page Experience signals
• Can impact search rankings, especially in competitive scenarios
• Affects user engagement metrics, which indirectly influence SEO
• May influence Quality Score in Google Ads for landing pages

Best Practices for CLS Optimization

1. Prioritize Above-the-Fold Content: Focus on minimizing shifts in the initially visible viewport
2. Use CSS Containment: Isolate parts of the page to prevent layout shifts from propagating
3. Implement Lazy Loading Carefully: Ensure lazy-loaded content doesn't cause layout shifts
4. Optimize for Mobile: Pay special attention to CLS on mobile devices where space is limited
5. Monitor CLS Regularly: Use Real User Monitoring (RUM) to track CLS in the field

Advanced CLS Considerations

CLS in Single Page Applications (SPAs)

SPAs present unique challenges for CLS measurement and optimization:

• Ensure smooth transitions between views without causing layout shifts
• Pre-render critical content to minimize shifts during route changes
• Use skeleton screens or placeholders for content that loads asynchronously

Balancing CLS with Other Performance Metrics

Optimizing for CLS should be balanced with other performance considerations:

• Weigh the benefits of lazy loading against potential layout shifts
• Consider the impact of font optimization techniques on First Contentful Paint (FCP)
• Balance the use of prefetching for improved CLS against increased data usage

Future of CLS and Web Performance

• Integration with Web Design Tools: Expect CLS considerations to be built into design and development tools
• Machine Learning Optimization: AI-driven tools may help predict and prevent layout shifts during development
• Evolution of CLS Measurement: The metric may evolve to account for more nuanced user experiences
• Increased Importance in SEO: As user experience signals grow in importance, CLS may play an even larger role in search rankings

In conclusion, Cumulative Layout Shift is a critical metric for assessing and improving the visual stability of web pages. By understanding CLS and implementing strategies to minimize unexpected layout shifts, web developers and SEO professionals can significantly enhance user experience, improve search engine rankings, and ultimately drive better engagement and conversions on their websites. As web technologies and user expectations continue to evolve, maintaining good CLS scores will remain an essential aspect of web development and optimization.

Master Core Web Vitals

Want to dive deeper into Core Web Vitals and other crucial SEO factors? Explore our comprehensive SEO Glossary to enhance your understanding of search engine optimization and improve your website's performance in search results.